HestiaCP or KarnakPanel? Both answers, honestly.
HestiaCP is a good panel, it is genuinely free, and for a lot of admins it is the correct choice. This page is the split: what you gain, what you give up, and the cases where the honest advice is to stay where you are.
Three reasons to stay on HestiaCP.
If any of these describe you, this page can save you a fortnight: stop reading and keep the panel.
- You need a distribution we do not support. HestiaCP installs across a wide range of Linux distributions. KarnakPanel is Ubuntu 24.04 LTS or Debian 13, and nothing else.
- You need MySQL 8 or PostgreSQL. HestiaCP supports MariaDB, MySQL 8 and PostgreSQL. KarnakPanel ships MariaDB only.
- You run PHP 5.6 to 8.1 for legacy customers. HestiaCP covers 5.6 through 8.3. KarnakPanel is 8.3 to 8.5, which is a deliberate choice and a real limitation if you host old code.
Two more, less about features: it is GPLv3 software maintained by a community you can join, and it is nginx underneath, which means the Apache-style configuration people have in muscle memory behaves more like it does on Apache. If any of that is the reason you chose it, those are good reasons.
Where they actually differ.
HestiaCP figures are from its own feature list at v1.10.6. Ours are from this site. Nothing in this table claims a feature they have is missing — where they have it, it says so.
| HestiaCP 1.10.6 | KarnakPanel 1.5.57 | |
|---|---|---|
| Licence | GPLv3, community-maintained | Free, no licence server, no per-account fee |
| Web server | nginx + Apache2, or nginx + PHP-FPM | OpenLiteSpeed with LSCache |
| PHP | 5.6 to 8.3, 8.2 by default | 8.3 to 8.5, one PHP master per account with its own CPU, memory and process limits |
| Operating system | Broad distribution support | Ubuntu 24.04 LTS, Debian 13 |
| Databases | MariaDB 10.2 to 10.11, MySQL 8, PostgreSQL | MariaDB, per-user grants |
| Site builder | Not in the feature list | Karnak Builder: drag and drop, 75 templates, static HTML out |
| One-click apps | Eleven apps via CLI or the admin panel | Seven installers, with staging clones and fleet-wide updates |
| Backups | SFTP, FTP and Rclone to 50+ storage providers | Encrypted incrementals, offsite mirror to S3 or SFTP, optional restic engine with restore tests |
| DNS | Own nameservers, DNS clusters, DNSSEC support | Own nameservers, one-click DNSSEC with DS output, per-name resolver check after a cutover |
| Exim and Dovecot, per-domain TLS, relay for blocked port 25, adjustable rate limits | Exim and Dovecot, per-account PHP mail caps, mail guard, deliverability scoring, CalDAV/CardDAV | |
| Migration in | Not assessed here | cPanel (three routes), HestiaCP (two routes), mailbox import from any IMAP host |
| Automation | API, custom themes and web templates, CLI for everything | REST and provisioning APIs, WHMCS server module, admin and reseller roles |
| Security model | 2FA, chroot jails, SSH keys | Passkeys and 2FA, per-account isolation by design, signed updates, internal review with independent review outstanding |
Two rows where HestiaCP is ahead on paper, and we are not going to argue with them: database choice, and the range of operating systems and PHP versions it will run on. Two rows where we are: the site builder, and what a hosting account is isolated from.
The two design decisions that matter.
Feature tables are easy to read and hard to act on. These are the differences that change how the server behaves on a bad day.
Per-account PHP, not per-server
Every account gets its own PHP master with its own CPU, memory and process limits, so one customer's runaway script is capped rather than shared. That is the same mechanism behind the Firewall page's PHP workers report: when an account runs out of workers you can see which IPs were hitting it in those seconds and block one from the list.
A builder inside the panel
Karnak Builder publishes static HTML to any domain on the server, with 75 templates, nine site styles, version history and a blog with RSS. It is not Wix and it is not pretending to be: it is there so a reseller can hand a customer a site without a WordPress install, a theme licence or a plugin update schedule. HestiaCP's feature list has no equivalent, which matters if selling simple sites is part of your business and does not matter at all if it is not.
If you do switch, the accounts come with you.
This is the part that decides whether a panel change is a project or an afternoon, so it gets its own section.
- HestiaCP import, two ways. Root over SSH, or an uploaded backup. Neither route needs you to rebuild sites by hand.
- What arrives: sites and subdomains, databases with their passwords, mailboxes, forwarders, DNS records, and cron jobs left paused so nothing fires against half-moved data.
- What is yours: the registrar, certificate reissue, DKIM and DMARC per sending domain, and starting cron once you have read it. The migration page covers this in the order it needs to happen, because the sequence is the same whichever panel you left.
- Batch moves: HestiaCP sources are one job per account, with their own progress and logs. What bulk means on each route is worth reading if you are moving more than a handful.
- Panel to panel: once both ends are KarnakPanel, Account Transfer ticks many accounts, runs a live bar per account and cuts over in one step with a rollback if it stops.
What you would be giving up here.
The honest list, in the same detail as the gains.
The ones people actually ask.
Short answers.
Is KarnakPanel a drop-in replacement for HestiaCP?
No. The account model is similar and the importer exists, but the web server, the supported operating systems, the PHP range and the database engine all differ. A server running HestiaCP is not one configuration change away from running this.
Which is faster?
We are not going to publish a benchmark we did not run, and a benchmark of two panels is mostly a benchmark of two web servers on one machine. If throughput is your deciding factor, test it on your own hardware with your own sites rather than taking either vendor's chart on faith.
Do I still pay anything?
Both panels are free. What you pay for is the server, and in KarnakPanel's case your own time operating it. There is no per-account licence on either — which is the part that makes both of these cheaper than a cPanel server, as the pricing page works out.
What if I am on cPanel, not HestiaCP?
The cPanel migration page is the one you want: three routes in, including a remote import that needs no root on the old server.